Search by
Neighborhood
City
County
State
Country
Postal Code
Subdivision
Street Address
Property Name
MLS ID
Listing ID
Public School
School District
Office Name
Elaine C. Stimmel
Phone:
(516) 445-4543
ES@Saunders.com
Home
My Listings
SALES
RENTALS
RECENTLY SOLD
My Profile
Property Search
SALES
RENTALS
OUR APPROACH
ABOUT THE SAUNDERS BRAND
SAUNDERS SALES BOOK
HAMPTONS DEVELOPERS
HAPPENING IN THE HAMPTONS
SAUNDERS OFFICES
RECENT AWARDS
MARKET INTELLIGENCE
HAMPTONS GUIDES
Log in
More
Menu
manage locations
Location
Map
Draw Area
Radius
School District
manage locations
Period
(0
selected
)
January
February
March
April
May
April/May
MD-LD
June
July
August
August-LD
July-August-LD
June/July
September
October
September/October
November
December
Extended Season
Year Round
Winter
Weekly
Two Weeks
Short Term
Custom
Price
Price
Currency :
USD
Price
Any
1+
2+
3+
4+
5+
Any
1+
2+
3+
4+
5+
Virtual
(0
selected
)
Virtual Tour 3D
Videos
Property Type
(0
selected
)
Apartment
Condominium
Multi-Family Home
Single Family Home
Townhouse
Commercial
Square Feet
Square Feet
Square Feet
Amenities
(0
selected
)
Artist Studio
Barn
Central Air Conditioning
Dock
Finished Lower Level
Garage
Guest House
Main Level Master Suite
New Construction
Pool
Pool House
South of The Highway
Room for Tennis/Pool
Tennis
Waterfront
Waterview
Any
Today
Tomorrow
Next 7 Days
Upcoming Weekend
All
Acres
Acres
Acres
Any
Today
Within 1 Week
Within 1 Month
Beyond 12 Months
Beyond 24 months
New Construction
Save
Less
More
Advanced Search
Cancel
refine
65 Real Estate Listings for Rent in Shelter Island
Gallery
Hybrid
Map
filter: by state
Default
Price High-Low
Price Low-High
New Listings First
Old Listings First
Beds Low-High
Beds High-Low
Baths Low-High
Baths High-Low
Sq Foot High-Low
selected listings
select all
remove all
E-mail
Print
Compare
Route Planner
Save
images
contact
map
1
of 15
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Wades Beach Chic Cottage On The Dunes
Wades Beach Chic Cottage On The Dunes
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$120,000
Year Round
3
2
1.16
1.1K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 23
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Cheery Renovated Shelter Island Farmhouse Near Marina
Cheery Renovated Shelter Island Farmhouse Near Marina
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$72,000
Year Round
4
2
.9
2.1K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 27
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Iconic Shelter Island Village Traditional With Pool
Iconic Shelter Island Village Traditional With Pool
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$60,000
August
Rental Rates
August-LD
$65,000
5
3
.35
3.9K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 16
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Heights Renovated Apartment
Shelter Island Heights Renovated Apartment
Shelter Island
,
NY
11965
$42,000
Year Round
1
.12
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 24
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Sleek And Chic Waterfront
Shelter Island Sleek And Chic Waterfront
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$40,000
June
Rental Rates
June/July
$90,000
4
2
.46
3.1K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 23
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Classic Traditional In Quiet Hilo Shores
Classic Traditional In Quiet Hilo Shores
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$38,500
August-LD
4
2
.7
2.2K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 29
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Lush And Lovely Shelter Island With Pool
Lush And Lovely Shelter Island With Pool
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$38,000
July
4
4
.97
2.4K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 24
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Stunning Shelter Island Water View With Pool And Tennis
Stunning Shelter Island Water View With Pool And Tennis
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$35,000
June
Rental Rates
Two Weeks
$35,000
Custom
$40,000
5
5
2.9
4.3K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 49
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Modern With Pool
Shelter Island Modern With Pool
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$35,000
July
Rental Rates
Custom
$40,000
3
3
1
2.9K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 17
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Waterfront With Pool
Shelter Island Waterfront With Pool
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$35,000
July
Rental Rates
August-LD
$37,000
3
4
2.3
3.2K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 26
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Newly Renovated 1911 Plantation Style Home
Newly Renovated 1911 Plantation Style Home
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$30,000
June
Rental Rates
July
$40,000
August-LD
$50,000
6
4
6
4K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
images
contact
map
1
of 29
Elaine C. Stimmel
Licensed Associate Real Estate Broker
(516) 445-4543
(631) 405-3622
Email Me
Saunders & Associates
Shelter Island Picturesque Farmhouse With Pool
Shelter Island Picturesque Farmhouse With Pool
Shelter Island
,
NY
11964
$30,000
July
8
3
.94
2.7K
Listing Courtesy of:
Penelope A. Moore
Saunders & Associates
1
2
3
4
5
6
Google Map Loading...
ade294f72-eaba-45e6-805b-2f886a0cd5f7